The consenting process in the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA) is being replaced by two new regimes: land use activities and subdivision will be governed by "planning consents" under the Planning Act, while activities relating to the natural environment will require a "natural resource permit" under the Natural Environment Act.

This update explains what that split will mean for practitioners advising on projects that touch both Acts.  We cover the new consenting regimes, and the key requirements relating to notification and submissions, hearings, and levies.

What are consents and permits?

When the new regimes take full effect, what were previously all called "resource consents" will be split into two new categories: "planning consents" under the Planning Act, and "natural resource permits" under the Natural Environment Act.  Planning consents are further divided into "land use consents" and "subdivision consents", while natural resource permits are divided into four types:

  • Coastal permits, permitting someone to do something in the coastal marine area that would otherwise not be permitted

  • Discharge permits, permitting the discharge of contaminants into or onto land

  • Land use permits, permitting the use of land (including the bed of a river or lake) in a manner that contravenes relevant rules

  • Water permits, permitting the taking, using, damming or diverting of water.

Activity classification

Activities in the new Acts are classified into categories (permitted, controlled, restricted discretionary, discretionary and prohibited).  These categories largely mirror those in the RMA, but the RMA's "non-complying activity" is absent from the new Acts.  Controlled activities are only a category under the Natural Environment Act, with no equivalent in the Planning Act.

Timeframes

The same statutory time frames apply for consent and permit authorities to process consent and permit applications as exist under the RMA, albeit regulations can set shorter time frames.  Under both Acts, these range from a maximum of 45 working days for non-notified consents without hearings, up to 130 working days for publicly notified consents with a hearing.  These timeframes begin when an application is lodged and end when a consent or permit is issued.  The RMA already provides overall statutory processing periods for different categories of resource consent application, assembled through time limits applying to successive procedural steps and subject to specified clock stops and extensions.  The new Acts instead state the applicable processing period directly by reference to the application’s notification and hearing pathway, running from lodgement until the consent or permit is issued, subject to the Acts’ timing provisions.

Consent and permit durations

Consent and permit durations follow a similar logic to that in the RMA.  Under the Planning Act, planning consents are granted for an unlimited period by default (unless the consent specifies otherwise).  Consents lapse five years after commencement (or 10 years for a renewable energy activity), unless given effect to or extended by the consent authority beforehand.

Under the Natural Environment Act, natural resource permits are granted for five years by default, with permit authorities able to specify a period of up to 35 years.  This is subject to exceptions for reclamation coastal permits and land use permits (unlimited, unless specified); wastewater and stormwater infrastructure permits (fixed at 35 years); renewable energy and long-lived infrastructure permits (35 to 50 years); and aquaculture coastal permits (20 to 35 years).

Effects

A consent or permit authority's discretion to consider effects is more constrained under the new Acts, when compared to the RMA.

Under the Planning Act, only adverse effects on persons (other than those who have given written approval) and the built environment may be considered, although all positive and cumulative effects continue to be relevant.  The Planning Act specifies a range of further effects that consent authorities must disregard, including adverse effects permitted in relevant plans (changing the permitted baseline from discretionary to mandatory), trade competition effects, effects relating to financial viability, and precedent effects.  The most significant of these changes is the narrowing of landscape values as a relevant effect: views from private property and effects on landscape can no longer be considered unless the landscape is an outstanding natural landscape or an area of high natural character, which in practice confines protection of landscape values to a much narrower set of circumstances than under the RMA.  Some of these changes come into play under the RMA during the transitional period, as discussed in our earlier article.

The Natural Environment Act is similarly restrictive, limiting consideration to adverse effects on persons and natural resources, and mandating the use of the permitted baseline.

The new Acts also replace the RMA’s familiar direction to “avoid, remedy, or mitigate” adverse effects with a more detailed statement of the available effects-management responses, expressly recognising avoidance, mitigation, remediation, offsetting, and compensation.  Importantly, this is not an effects-management hierarchy: section 18(2)of the Planning Act and section 17(2) of the Natural Environment Act expressly do not assign an order of priority.  However, national instruments may develop and refine this approach.

Relevance of key instruments in decision making

Discretion during decision making is further restricted in terms of the documents that consent and permit authorities may consider (referred to as "key instruments" in both Acts).  These key instruments are:

  • National policy directions

  • National standards

  • Regional spatial plans

  • Land use plans (Planning Act) and natural environment plans (Natural Environment Act).

Consent and permit authorities' ability to consider these key instruments is limited, with decision makers only able to consider relevant provisions of higher order instruments where the relevant matter is not addressed by the instrument listed beneath it.  This is a significant departure from the RMA position, where consideration of relevant provisions of higher-order documents (such as the NZCPS) is mandatory.

Neither of the new Acts contains an equivalent provision to RMA s 104(1)(c), which gave RMA consent authorities a general discretion to consider any other relevant matter, where reasonably necessary to decide the application.

Conditions

Conditions regimes in both Acts largely resemble the RMA.  Conditions must only be imposed where they are agreed by the applicant, directly address an adverse effect of the activity or applicable rule, or are essential for the efficient implementation of the planning consent.

Notification and submissions

Public participation rights under the new Acts are significantly narrowed compared with the RMA: fewer applications will be publicly notified, and only a "qualifying person" or an "affected person" may make submissions on notified applications.  To be a qualifying person, someone must be a ratepayer, infrastructure provider, resident, or business operator within the relevant district.

We have developed the three-step test below which shows the process for determining whether an application must be notified and highlights the default towards targeted rather than public notification.

Step 1 – Do the "mandatory" public notification criteria apply?

Applies where the applicant requests it, the application is made jointly with an application to exchange recreation reserve land under the Reserves Act 1977, or a national rule or plan rule requires it.

Step 2A – Is notification required to certain groups or "targeted notification" required?

If mandatory public notification does not apply, notification is required to any of the following affected groups or persons that can be identified:

  • Affected protected customary rights groups

  • Affected customary marine title groups

  • Affected persons (discussed below) to whom a statutory acknowledgement applies.

If any of these groups or persons can be identified, they must be notified.

Step 2B – Are there other "affected persons" and can they all be identified?

The authority must then decide whether there are "affected persons" and whether all of them can be identified.

Under both Acts, someone is an affected person if they will experience more than minor adverse effects from an activity.  Under the Natural Environment Act, this also extends to more than minor effects on persons within a management unit (even if the effect on an individual is minor).

If there are affected persons, then they must be notified and the permit authority must not publicly notify the application (targeted notification).

If there are no affected persons or they cannot all be identified, then Step 3 applies (public notification).

Step 3 – Does the application need to be publicly notified?

An application under the Planning Act must be publicly notified only if the activity's adverse effects are, or are likely to be, "more than minor" and there are no affected persons, or they cannot all be identified.

An application under the Natural Environment Act must be publicly notified only if it will have, or is likely to have, "significant" adverse effects on natural resources or people, and there are no affected persons, or they cannot all be identified.

If these requirements do not apply, the application does not need to be notified.

Unlike the RMA, neither Act includes a general “special circumstances” test permitting notification where the ordinary statutory criteria are not met.  This removes the residual discretion available under the RMA and makes the statutory notification pathways more prescriptive.  For many applicants, this will provide a welcome change and additional certainty on notification decisions.

Hearings, appeals and reviews

Applications for planning consents and natural environment permits may be heard jointly if they relate to the same proposal.  The exact process for this will be specified in regulations to be issued later.

Both Acts impose limits on the ability to hold hearings, with hearings only allowed if requested by an applicant or submitter, and in the latter case only if the relevant authority considers a hearing to be the most effective and efficient means to test the application and the parties have attended a mediation (if the commissioner considers it appropriate).

An applicant, consent holder, or submitter may appeal an authority's decision to the Environment Court.  A notice of appeal must be lodged with the Environment Court and served on the relevant authority within 15 working days of the decision.

A new decision-making body, the Planning Tribunal, will be established by the Planning Act.  Applicants will have a right of review to the Tribunal (rather than the Court) in relation to various process-related decisions, including notification and deferral decisions, and decisions on the completeness of applications.

Levies

Both Acts enable cost-recovery levies to be created by regulation, though the two levy regimes differ in scope and design.

Planning consent levy

The Planning Act enables the Minister to set planning consent levies by regulation, to cover the cost of developing and reviewing national instruments and system performance monitoring, including associated data collection.  Consent authorities are responsible for collecting the money and paying it directly to the Ministry for Cities, Environment, Regions, and Transport (MCERT).

The Government has also signalled through the Local Government (Infrastructure Funding) Amendment Bill that it intends to replace the current development contribution system with a new development levy regime to help councils pay for the infrastructure needed to support growth.  The new development levies system will give councils and water organisations greater flexibility to charge developers for the overall cost of growth infrastructure.

Natural resource levies

Natural resource levies are a new concept under the Natural Environment Act and they fall into two categories: levies addressing overallocation and efficient use within a management unit, and levies covering the costs of managing a resource.  Natural resource levies may be set by the Minister in regulations or by regional councils within prescribed parameters but like planning consent levies, much of the detail is left to regulations.

In practice these new levies represent a new cost exposure beyond existing consent and permit fees.  Applicants seeking natural resource permits in higher-demand catchments or for higher-demand resources should be advised early that levy regulations may introduce cost implications.

Key takeaways

Two central themes emerge from the new consenting regimes: reduced decision-maker discretion, including tighter limits on the effects and instruments that may be considered, and narrower opportunities for public participation.  In principle, this should reduce the range of matters open for reconsideration through an individual consenting process and limit the number of people entitled to participate.

Over time, the reforms are intended to deliver simpler and more predictable consenting processes, reduce the need for consent in some circumstances, and lower costs for system users. In the short term, however, practitioners and decision makers will need to navigate an unfamiliar system.  Much of its practical operation remains uncertain and will depend on regulations, national instruments and implementation by consent and permit authorities.

Co-authored by Jack Parker (Senior Solicitor).